Mifflinburg PA Homes for Sale
Mifflinburg is a borough in Union County, in the Central Susquehanna Valley. It sits on Route 45, and the Susquehanna River Valley Visitors Bureau calls it “Buggy Town.”
Current Listings in Mifflinburg
These are the homes currently listed for sale with a Mifflinburg, PA address. Open any listing for photos and full details.
Mid Penn Market Pulse
Mifflinburg PA 17844 Real Estate Market Update
The 12 months ending October 31, 2026
Median Sale Price
Median Days on Market
Median Sale-to-List Ratio
Months of Supply
Thirty-two homes sold in ZIP 17844 in the twelve months from November 1, 2025 through October 31, 2026, at a median price of $252,450. Half spent 18 days or less on the market, and the median home sold for 96.1 percent of its final asking price. The ZIP carried an average of about 8 homes for sale a month, which works out to about 2.9 months of supply. (Source: FlexMLS, ZIP 17844, residential closed sales and monthly active listings, November 2025 through October 2026, as recorded November 2, 2026.) Some October 2026 sales may not be recorded yet, so any figure in this update that includes October 2026 may change. These figures reflect FlexMLS as of November 2, 2026.
In the same twelve months a year earlier, 57 homes sold at a median of $285,000, so the median for the latest twelve months was 11.4 percent lower, on far fewer sales. The share of sales at $400,000 or more was almost the same in both years, 12.5 percent against 12.3 percent, so the difference is not a change at the top end. With only 32 sales, a handful of sales can move that comparison by several points, so we do not read it as a drop in what a Mifflinburg home is worth. (Source: FlexMLS, ZIP 17844, residential closed sales, November 2025 through October 2026 compared with November 2024 through October 2025, as recorded November 2, 2026.)
Do not read the Union County number as a Mifflinburg number
Union County's median sale price over the same twelve months was $313,800, across 256 sales, 0.9 percent above the twelve months before. Mifflinburg's median, as noted above, was lower on far fewer sales. (Source: FlexMLS, Union County, residential closed sales, November 2025 through October 2026 compared with November 2024 through October 2025, as recorded November 2, 2026.)
The county figure is mostly someone else's market. Of the county's 256 sales, 148 were in Lewisburg's ZIP 17837 and 32 in Mifflinburg's ZIP 17844. A Mifflinburg seller who reads the county headline as a statement about their own house would be reading it wrong.
This is why we publish the towns and not just the county.
Priced to Sell, or Priced to Sit
Fifteen homes in ZIP 17844 spent two weeks or less on the market, and none of them finished with a list price below where it started. Six homes sat for 90 days or more, and five of the six finished with a list price below where it started. Homes that spent 15 to 89 days on the market fall in neither group, and these counts may change as late October sales are recorded. (Source: FlexMLS, ZIP 17844, residential closed sales, November 2025 through October 2026, as recorded November 2, 2026.)
Six homes is a small group, so we report the direction rather than a percentage. The direction is clear: in Mifflinburg, a long time on the market went with a lower list price.
For a specific Mifflinburg property, the comparable sales nearby say more than any median on this page.
Data source: FlexMLS, ZIP 17844, residential closed sales, November 1, 2025 through October 31, 2026. 32 closed sales. One listing was excluded for a sale-to-list ratio outside 50 to 150 percent. Prior year comparison: 57 closed sales, November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2025. Inventory and months of supply from FlexMLS monthly active listings, November 2025 through October 2026. Union County figures from FlexMLS, Union County, residential closed sales, the same twelve months, 256 closed sales. Retrieved November 2, 2026.
Updated November 2, 2026, 6:54 PM ET
Living in Mifflinburg
Downtown and History
Mifflinburg began as two towns. Elias Youngman laid out Youngmanstown in 1792, and by 1799 it was the largest town in Buffalo Valley. In 1827 Youngmanstown and Rotestown were incorporated into the borough of Mifflinburg, named for Thomas Mifflin, the first governor of Pennsylvania. A bend in the streets marks where the two towns joined.
In 1825 a turnpike joined Mifflinburg east to Lewisburg and Northumberland and west to Aaronsburg and Bellefonte. The first railroad from Lewisburg to Mifflinburg was built in 1871.
The Mifflinburg Historic District has a National Register of Historic Places record, published in 1980, that lists industry, commerce, transportation and architecture as its areas of significance. The visitors bureau also points to the Gutelius House, an early 19th-century home, and to a self-guided walking tour through town.
Buggy Making
Buggy manufacturing began in Mifflinburg in the 1840s. The borough’s history records that in 1899 its buggy works made more than 2,000 buggies, carriages and sleighs, which were sold across the U.S.
William Heiss made carriages, wagons and sleighs from 1883 to 1920. His house and buggy shop on Green Street have a National Register record dated 1979. The Mifflinburg Buggy Museum keeps the original Heiss coachworks building, and the bureau describes the museum as the Heiss family home with a carriage house, factory and showroom.
The bureau lists guided tours of about an hour on weekend afternoons, May through October.
Community Park and Pool
Mifflinburg Community Park is on North Fifth Street. It has a swimming pool, a playground, covered pavilions, picnic tables and a gazebo, it hosts concerts in the park, and there is room for tennis, basketball and ball games. The park’s page also posts rules for its dog park.
The community pool has diving and sliding boards, and the borough offers swim lessons there for levels 1 to 4. The Herr Memorial Library is in Mifflinburg as well.
The Buffalo Valley Rail Trail
The Buffalo Valley Rail Trail runs from N. 10th Street in Mifflinburg to Market Street in Lewisburg. It follows the route of a railroad that once ran from Montandon, in Northumberland County, to Bellefonte in Centre County. The line stopped running in 1982.
The Union County Trail Authority, created by the Union County Board of Commissioners in 2018, owns and manages the trail. Its first phase was finished in the fall of 2011, and the authority gives the trail’s length as 9.5 miles. It lists biking, walking, inline skating, mountain biking, cross-country skiing and wheelchair access among the trail’s uses, and the route runs parallel to Route 45.
Through the Year
The museum holds Buggy Day on the second Saturday in June. Oktoberfest is an annual celebration. The Christkindl Market, which its organizers hold each year in December, and Winterfest take place on the historic downtown streets.
Schools and the Borough Office
Mifflinburg is in the Mifflinburg Area School District. The district also serves the boroughs of New Berlin and Hartleton, and townships including Buffalo, Hartley, Lewis, Limestone and West Buffalo.
Because the district reaches past the borough line, confirm the municipality and school district on any listing you are weighing. The borough office is at 120 N Third Street, Mifflinburg, PA 17844.
More Town Pages
Our community pages list every town page on the site.
Questions about a home in Mifflinburg? Call Mid Penn Realty, 570-387-8300, or visit our office at 128 West Main Street, Suite 101, Bloomsburg, PA 17815.
